‘This is the end, my only friend the end.’
I’ll be honest I do have other friends, but sadly this is the end of this series of outpourings (I’m self aware enough to know I’ve lost the battle with restraint on several occasions over the last 8 weeks), and hopefully you’ve picked up on why I use a lot of music and film references? I’ll explain anyway even though I know you got it really, it’s our old friend context again, nothing happens in a vacuum even architecture. We can’t really tackle a subject without acknowledging what is effecting, directly or indirectly, the people and happenings we’re talking about.
There’s some irony in our subject matter this week, we’ve already talked about capitalism and nuclear war and the general end of the world it seems fitting that the end of this blog should focus on the country that many believe will or could have been responsible for the end of us all. The text of choice is USA by John Dos Passos, in particular 3 biographies of Frank Lloyd Wright, Henry Ford and Torstein Veblen.
So three very different people, an architect (well this is an architecture blog), a car maker and a thinker/author. Now I know what you’re thinking ‘what have these guys got in common apart from all having carked it?’ well its tragedy, they all had ideas which they hoped would change the world, but in some cases ended up recoiling away from it, in case you hadn’t already guessed we’re not dealing with a great deal of happiness today, so if your disposition leans towards the negative now may be the time to pop a happy pill.
Henry Ford changed production forever let’s not mess around on that one, his ideas on mass production, ‘the production line’, have effected manufacturing and are still evident today. How he achieved this was probably in no small way effected by his megalomaniacal side, we’ve all got one some of us are better at keeping it in check than others! Ford believed that progression would be achieved through values; his values to be specific, Ford decided that his workers shouldn’t drink, smoke, gamble or get into debt. Sounds like a real bucket of fun this guy, haven’t got one of those happy pills spare have you? For all his success Ford recoiled away from society, recreating his childhood in a rural small town with no roads!
Torstein next, well you didn’t think i was going to let you skip through anything by cutting straight to the architect did you? Famously dubbed the man, who couldn’t say yes, he refused to compromise on his principles, would agree to anything that might impinge on his modus operandi. He’s a little like the character Paul in Decline and Fall, can’t get in the game, prefers to sit watching the people struggling on the wheel of life. Veblen ended up living in a shack in Palo Alto.
So finally we’re at Frank Lloyd Wright and we’ve only got ourselves another megalomaniac, what are the odds? Frank was known for bullying his clients; he famously insisted one client must forgo having a bed in their shiny new house and sleep on a futon! I think i said it last week, what kind of architect are you if you don’t actually deliver something that works for your client, if it doesn’t work from them then what’s the point!!
Frank had his share of tragedy; his own home burnt to the ground twice, and was the site of
So this is all great but what does it mean? Henry saw his dreams come true and recoiled from the world he changed, Veblen sought to understand the world and succeeded, perhaps understanding the US population better than almost anyone, and he recoiled away from it. Now Frank he, like Corbusier never saw his dreams come true, they never saw their new utopian cities created. Would he have recoiled away from that city? Would it be another Milton Keynes?
‘you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become a villain’ – that’s Batman, now I’m not suggesting that these guys are villains although I’m not sure that there’s ever been a heroic megalomaniac – answers on a post card. I’m suggesting there megalomaniacal tendencies blocked their path to the changes to humanity they were desperate to make, we rarely get anywhere entirely on our own after all.
So who’s the odd one out, drum roll please............. its Torstein! While Ford and Frank Busied themselves building monuments to their ideals that would stand long after they were gone, Torstein only sought to understand, requesting at the end that there be no ceremony, no memorial built. Just goes to show if you stop the me me me for 5 minutes you might come up with some ideas you can live with long term and there’s where the virtue is my friend.